Fanatics and American Express have built a credit card around fandom itself, with FanCash paying 5% across the Fanatics ecosystem and card faces drawn from a roster of 500-plus athletes. There’s no annual fee, and that’s the hook.
FanCash pays best inside the Fanatics ecosystem

Spending at Fanatics.com, Mitchell & Ness, Lids, Fanatics Collect, Fanatics Live and Topps.com earns 5% back in FanCash.
Purchases through the Fanatics App earn 8% or more, because the app adds at least 3% on top of the base rate.
FanCash spends across the platform on apparel, trading cards, collectibles, tickets and entry to events like Fanatics Fest.
Tickets and select streaming services earn 5% too, and the fine print caps 5% earning at select fandom merchants at $5,000 of annual spending. Everywhere else, the card pays 2%.
I read that split as a loyalty test, since a fan who buys jerseys and cards monthly will clear the 5% tiers without changing a single habit.
The bonuses reward steady spending, not a sprint

New cardholders receive $100 in FanCash after spending $1,000 within 90 days of account opening, and a second $100 follows $500 of spending in each of 12 months.
The math stays plain here, because $100 back on $1,000 of spending pays 10% during that window, and the card charges no annual fee against it. Steady fans collect both bonuses.
Cardholders also collect 2,500 Fanatics ONE tier points at account opening and again on each anniversary, plus 10 tier points for every $50 they spend.
Membership Rewards members can also move points into FanCash at 1,000 points for $10 in FanCash, and the card itself is issued by First Electronic Bank on the American Express network, with Imprint powering the program.
A Fanatics ONE account is required, and invitations to apply start going out later this year to fans on the waitlist in the United States.
Quarterly presales give cardholders early access to a select Topps release each year, and Fanatics Fest adds early floor access plus a cardmember gift.
A Championship Challenge entry adds a game on top, asking cardholders to predict the MLB, NBA, NFL and NHL champions for a chance at a spending-back prize capped at $100,000.
Cardholders also get Amex Offers for shopping, dining and travel, plus presale access to select sports, music and theater events through the network.
We’ll take 5% over points.