A guide to the best toaster ovens – for that perfect dish

A good toaster oven earns its counter space every single day, not just on pizza night. It toasts breakfast, crisps leftovers without waking the big oven, bakes a tray of cookies for two people instead of twelve, and handles the small jobs a full range makes feel absurd.

The five below span the category as it stands now, from a dial-driven Cuisinart workhorse at $129.95 to a dedicated Breville pizza oven at $999.95, with an air-fry specialist, a family-size smart oven, and a Japanese steam toaster in between. Every price was checked on Amazon today. Readers working through the rest of the kitchen can pair this with our vacuum cleaner guide and the smart speaker picks from the same series.

1. Cuisinart Air Fryer Toaster Oven Combo TOA-55

The sensible starting point. The TOA-55 packs seven functions and 1800 watts into a stainless box run entirely by four chunky dials, so there is no menu to learn and nothing to update. Turn, set, cook.

The TOA-55 front panel and air fry basket, dials for time, temperature, function and shade. Photo: Cuisinart
Cuisinart Air Fryer Toaster Oven Combo TOA-55Save $80.00 · 38% off
7-in-1 countertop combo
1800W
Dial controls for function, temperature and shade
$129.95 $209.95

Dial control is a feature, not a compromise. Glance across the kitchen and you can read the settings from the knob positions alone, and a houseguest can run it without a briefing.

At $80 under list, this is where most kitchens should start.

2. Ninja Digital Air Fry Countertop Oven SP101

The low, wide one. Ninja stretches the cavity sideways instead of stacking it tall, so the SP101 slides into the gap under upper cabinets that shuts out boxier ovens, and its XL interior still takes a full sheet-pan dinner.

The SP101 with its Crisp Control panel and the air fry basket and sheet pan it ships with. Photo: Ninja
Ninja Digital Air Fry Countertop Oven SP101Save $100.00 · 40% off
8-in-1 XL countertop oven
Crisp Control digital panel
Toast and bagel modes with slice and shade settings
$149.99 $249.99

The function list runs air fry, air roast, air broil, bake, dehydrate, keep warm, toast and bagel, all printed down the right-hand panel where you can see them in the photograph above. Wings in the basket, vegetables on the pan, toast for a crowd is the shape of an ordinary weeknight for this machine.

Renters and small kitchens get the most from it. The footprint spends width, which counters usually have, instead of height, which they often do not, and in a galley kitchen or a first apartment that single trade decides whether a toaster oven fits at all or stays in its box in a closet.

3. Breville Smart Oven Air Fryer Pro BOV900

The family oven that can retire the big one for weeks at a stretch. Breville fits thirteen cooking functions behind that amber display, and the cavity is sized for real roasts, as the chicken taking up the window in the photograph makes plain.

The BOV900 in brushed stainless steel, roast chicken inside, thirteen functions listed on the display. Photo: Breville
Breville Smart Oven Air Fryer Pro BOV900Save $80.00 · 20% off
13 cooking functions including air fry, proof and slow cook
Brushed stainless steel
Super convection air fry mode
$319.95 $399.95

Toast, bagel, broil, bake, roast, warm, pizza, proof, air fry, reheat, cookies, slow cook and dehydrate: the list is long because the oven is meant to absorb jobs from across the kitchen, including proofing dough and drying herbs from the garden.

Two dials and a confirm button run all of it, and a household that cooks daily will feel the difference within a week.

4. BALMUDA The Toaster Pro

The design piece, and the specialist. BALMUDA builds around steam, adding a small measure of water at the start of the cycle so bread crisps outside while the crumb stays soft, the signature trick of the Tokyo maker’s little ovens.

The Toaster Pro in black, two dials, temperature marks at 350, 400 and 450 degrees. Photo: BALMUDA
BALMUDA The Toaster ProSave $37.90 · 10% off
Steam oven toaster
6 modes including Shokupan and Golden Toast
Compact 14.1 by 12.6 by 8.2 inches
$341.10 $379.00

Six modes cover the breads this oven exists for, from shokupan milk bread to a golden toast finish, and the black cabinet with its brass-toned dials is the rare countertop appliance that improves the look of the counter it sits on.

It will not roast a chicken. Buy it for the morning ritual instead: bakery bread back to life, a croissant tasting fresh again.

5. Breville Smart Oven Pizzaiolo BPZ820

A single-purpose machine at the top of the page, priced like one. The Pizzaiolo is a countertop pizza oven whose style dial runs from 350 degrees up to 750, with presets named for the pies it is built to cook, and nothing else in a home kitchen outside a full range gets a crust anywhere near this territory without a steel, a stone, and an hour of preheating.

The Pizzaiolo in its Black Truffle finish; the card links the brushed stainless steel listing. Photo: Breville
Breville Smart Oven Pizzaiolo BPZ820
Style dial to 750°F
Presets for New York, Pan, Thin and Crispy, Frozen and Wood Fired styles
Brushed stainless steel
$999.95

New York, pan, thin and crispy, frozen, and a wood fired setting line the dial, with a darkness knob for the crust and a timer on the left. The stainless version up top is cooking a margherita with the leopard-spotted crust a hot deck gives a Neapolitan-style pie.

For a household with a standing pizza night, it replaces the delivery habit with something better and turns Friday into a small event. Everyone else on this page costs a third as much, which is exactly the calculation Breville expects you to make.

ProductPriceSaveBuy
Cuisinart TOA-55 Air Fryer Toaster Oven$129.95 $209.95$80.00Buy
Ninja SP101 Digital Air Fry Oven$149.99 $249.99$100.00Buy
Breville Smart Oven Air Fryer Pro BOV900$319.95 $399.95$80.00Buy
BALMUDA The Toaster Pro$341.10 $379.00$37.90Buy
Breville Smart Oven Pizzaiolo BPZ820$999.95Buy
Disclosure: dlmag uses affiliate links, If you click on a link in this article and buy something we’ll get a small cut of the sale.